Reviews Six published, forty-one openings studied Graded told, shown, discovered, mixed or withheld
The Tutorial Desk mark The Tutorial DeskFirst thirty minutes
Index

Every review, with its opening graded and timed

Ordered by time to competence, shortest first, because that single figure has turned out to predict more about how an opening feels than any other measurement we take.

A sunlit workshop with a broken cart wheel on a bench, tools ordered on a pegboard and a cat asleep on a sack
8.7FarmingShown

Hollowbrook Teaches An Entire Repair System With One Broken Wheel And No Words

Four minutes from launch to competence. A broken object, the tools beside it, and no instruction of any kind. Eleven of the fourteen rules in this opening are shown rather than told, which is the highest proportion in the file and not by a small margin.

4 min to competence14 rules52 hours played
A cluttered office desk at night with a green shaded lamp, a pinboard of photographs joined by coral thread and an open case file
7.8MysteryTold

Nine Witnesses Explains Its Deduction Rules Twice And Both Times Too Early

Eighteen minutes, most of them spent receiving explanations of systems that will not appear for another two hours. At the ten-hour retention check we could restate two of the four rules, which is a failure of ordering rather than of writing.

18 min to competence4 rules, 2 retained29 hours played
An open cockpit biplane on a grass airstrip at dawn with a mechanic's toolbox open on the grass and a windsock lifting
8.1FlightDiscovered

Updraught Lets You Crash For Half An Hour Before It Offers To Help

Forty-four minutes to competence and three destroyed aircraft on the way. The landing tutorial does not exist until the game has watched you fail, which is either the boldest decision in the file or a support ticket waiting to happen.

44 min to competence9 rules46 hours played